Tuesday, May 19, 2020

The Binocular Blog - Part 2: Purpose and Portability


Before running out to buy a pair of binoculars you must decide what you want one for. There are binoculars for different purposes and there is no universal pair that will be suitable for all. In fact, you might end up with more than one depending on the situation and purpose. Most of us have two or more cell phones and more than a few lying around at home, so it isn’t a difficult decision to buy a few! I have only five! 


Decide what it will be used for primarily. If you intend using it for wildlife viewing or bird watching, you might want to get something that will perform better in low light as birds and animals are active early in the morning or late evening. It would also help if it were well protected against the weather.

10x25 compact binoculars



If your purpose is sports a smaller one with slightly lesser magnification, 7x or so, should suffice. If you want to peep into your neighbour’s house a small unobtrusive one will ensure your safety!! However, if you want to do a bit of astronomy you will need high magnification bins that may be too heavy to hand hold and will need a tripod for stability. These big chaps will have high magnification (12x to 20x) and large objective lenses.  
8x42 binoculars
 A good compromise will be an 8x or 10x for most general-purpose use and I suggest keeping it in that range for your first purchase. As you use it and develop an interest in something specific and you can plan further upgrades around what you already possess.
  

10x42 binoculars
 
One other aspect of the binocular that has to be kept in mind is its size and weight. Just going by the magnification and objective size may not give you an idea what you will end up carrying. If you pick up four binoculars of the same specification, (let us say,10x40) from four different manufacturers they will be of different sizes and shapes. Overall, their weights might be about the same but the heft and the feel in your hands will be quite different. . 
Sourced from B&H Photo Video


Binoculars are generally classified according to their objective lens diameters. Compact binoculars have an objective lens diameter of less than 30 mm (8x25, 10x25 etc). Midsize ones have an objective lens diameter between 30 and 40 mm (8x32, 10x30 etc) The full-size binoculars have an objective diameter of 40 mm and above (8x42, 10x42, 12x50 etc)

(Pic courtesy: www.rei.com)


When you chose your binocular it should match the purpose. If your usage is primarily during the daytime and on treks, a compact binocular will be easier to carry. Even some midsize ones may fit in your bag. If your purpose is birding or wildlife viewing, you might have to go for a full sized instrument with 8x42 or 10x42 specification, as you are likely to be far away from your object of interest and these are the most comfortable for handholding. 

 
Weight comparison. Sourced from B&H Photo Video
If you are into astronomy you will need something with 12x or 15x and more magnification. These binoculars will get bulkier and will require a tripod to keep steady. They will be nearly impossible to handhold.  Their weights will increase (as in the above illustration) from under a kilogram to close to one. Having this hanging on your chest for hours together depends on the condition of your neck! It might be too much for an all day trial hike or even an extended birding trip.
 

So, before you rush out and grab the wrong pair. Sit down and analyze your requirement and your ability to carry it around. Smaller binoculars like a compact or the midsize with objective diameter of 32 mm should easily fit in a backpack with other things you might carry. Anything larger will need a proper harness or bigger bag. Spend a little time to decide the best one for you, otherwise you might regret it later.



For those who are impatient to go through the entire blog series, I'm giving below direct links to all the posts. You can go directly to the page you are interested in, though I suggest you go through each post as all of them contain some information that will be useful when you consider purchasing a binocular for your self.

1.       Introduction
2.       Part – 1: Anatomy of a Binocular
3.       Part – 2: Purpose and Portability
4.       Part – 3: Magnification, Objective diameter & FOV
5.       Part – 4: Eye Relief
6.       Part – 5: Exit pupil & Interpupillary distance
7.       Part – 6: Image brightness
8.       Part – 7: Focusing fundamentals
9.       Part – 8: Weather sealing
10.   Part – 9: Purchase decision
11.   Part – 10: Care & Storage
12.  Afterthoughts and accessories

The Binocular Blog - Part 1: The Anatomy of Binocular

Link to the previous post is here

Before making a decision about which binocular to buy you should familiarize yourself about the structure and function of the various components of the binocular. The binocular is essentially two monocular telescopes mounted together by a hinged bridge that usually carries a focusing ring. It is one of the most frequently purchased optical instruments anywhere in the world. While it looks like two simple tubes from outside, a lot goes into designing one. There is one for everyone and for every situation.

Anatomy of a Binocular (Pic courtesy: Olympus Asia)


Most early binoculars were simple telescopes with a convex lens in the front and a concave lens at the rear to erect the inverted image. They are the Galilean binoculars and were simple instruments  with limited magnification. Even now they are available in the form of opera glasses and toy binoculars. Modern binoculars use Keplerian optics, with convex lenses in both the front and rear of the telescope to achieve higher magnification. However, the resulting image is inverted and has to be made upright by some intervening prisms. (See the illustration above)

The lens that faces the object you are viewing, on the front of the instrument, is the objective lens and is the first component light encounters on its pathway to your eyes. The light then travels through the barrel, gets bounced off the prism surfaces and then exits through the eyepiece or ocular lens, into the viewer's eyes. The eyepiece lens group is also responsible for the magnification achieved by the binoculars. In all modern binoculars the objective and eyepiece lenses  are not made of a single lens but   combination of convex and concave lenses in groups. 

Objective and eyepiece lenses. (Pic courtesy: Nikon)

There are two basic types of binocular designs.  The traditional Porro prism binoculars in which the objective lens and the eyepiece are not aligned in a line and has a 'M' shape. In the sleeker roof prism binoculars the objective lens and the eye piece are in a straight line and has a 'H' shape. 




Older binoculars had the prisms that were in a Z shaped configuration and set apart. These are called Porro prism binoculars and are the design we are familiar with. Due to their design difference the light is transmitted through the Porro prism binoculars in a zig-zag path shape.The result is that Porro prism binoculars are bulkier but comfortable to hold and produce a steady image. They are also easier to adjust and give a better depth perception.    

Light transmission in binoculars (Pic courtesy: binocularsinsight.com)
In contrast,the newer binoculars, called roof prism binoculars have the prisms set back-to-back and aligned in a straight line with the objective and eyepiece, so the light passes without deviation from the objective lens to the eye. Therefore prism binoculars are sleek but need steadier hands and are less adjustable because of the closer setting of the oculars. People wide set eyes might find the pupillary distance adjustment not entirely to their satisfaction.

The focusing mechanism in both types are also different.The focusing wheel on Porro prism binoculars moves the eyepieces forward and backward to achieve optimum focus. This increases the length of the binocular and also makes it difficult to make it dust proof or waterproof.  

Porro prism binocular has external focusing by moving the eyepiece.
Whereas, in the roof prism binoculars the focusing is by shifting a group of lenses within the barrel so there is no change in the length of the instrument.These internal focus lenses are usually located between the objective lens and prisms and is moved by turning the focusing knob on the bridge.

 
Focusing ring on the roof prism binocular.
There are surprisingly a lot of different parts and accessories for an instrument so small. Technical descriptions are beyond me but any binocular user should know its different parts if you are planning to use one. Here are a series of photos showing the different parts of a binocular.





Once you familiarize yourself with the various parts and their names the rest of the blog that will be dealing with the functions will be easier to follow. The next blog deals how to select a binocular that suits your purpose. 

For those who are impatient to go through the entire blog series, I'm giving below direct links to all the posts. You can go directly to the page you are interested in, though I suggest you go through each post as all of them contain some information that will be useful when you consider purchasing a binocular for yourself.

1.       Introduction
2.       Part – 1: Anatomy of a Binocular
3.       Part – 2: Purpose and Portability
4.       Part – 3: Magnification, Objective diameter & FOV
5.       Part – 4: Eye Relief
6.       Part – 5: Exit pupil & Interpupillary distance
7.       Part – 6: Image brightness
8.       Part – 7: Focusing fundamentals
9.       Part – 8: Weather sealing
10.   Part – 9: Purchase decision
11.   Part – 10: Care & Storage
12.  Afterthoughts and accessories



(Apologies! Some parts of the blog has the font in a very small size and I'm quite unable to get it to  larger size despite several attempts. Can't seem to find a plausible reason for it.)